Jump to content


Photo

Do bugs feel pain?


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
9 replies to this topic

#1 Shulk

Shulk
  • Mario
  • 23,448 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 08:11 AM

OMG so I was driving into work this morning and as I was leaving the house I noticed one of those cute little green inch worms. I love those things! Mostly because they are green <3 :soawesome:

Anyways, as I start to get on the highway and pick up speed the little guy is having trouble hanging on and he starts to violently wiggle in the wind with his head smashing into the windshield over and over and over again. I kept saying "Hang in there little guy! I'll get you to a tree as soon as I get to work!" Suddenly when I break 60 mph WOOOOOOOOOSH! His last stand and his little sticky breaks loose and he flies off into the air. I can only assume he didn't make it.

I felt kind of bad for the little guy, but then I started to think OMG I wonder if he feels pain. I mean he was violently hitting my windshield in the progression of speed. I'd feel so terrible to think that he suffered.

What do you guys think, do bugs feel pain?

Lovesig2_zps472d6444.jpg


#2 Archangel

Archangel

    Turian Rebel

  • Retired Staff
  • 1,916 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 10:19 AM

They have nervous systems. So unless they have redundant nervous systems and don't feel pain, I'd think they do.

That's why when I see a spider or bug in my house I catch it and release it outside D:

#3 Keatos

Keatos

    It all returns to nothing

  • Retired Staff
  • 7,530 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 10:39 AM

"Pain" is actually a complicated subject, since there are different kinds of pain... Pain is both sensory and emotional. Like for example, you step on a nail which damages your nerves and sends signals up to your brain which make you emotionally distressed ("Ow, that hurts!") about your injury. While bugs can get hurt physically, we don't know if that translates into an emotional experience.

More intelligent creatures can feel pain in a way that we can understand, though. Unlike what every fisher has told you, fish do in fact feel pain and even fear in ways similar to a human. Some countries, like Germany, have even banned certain types of fishing for this reason.

Edited by Keatos, 20 April 2012 - 10:43 AM.

Posted Image


#4 Descole

Descole
  • Thwomp
  • 643 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 11:17 AM

http://insects.about...s-Feel-Pain.htm

In all likelihood, they do not feel pain (at least, not due to injury), but we don't have anything decisive.

Posted Image


#5 Shulk

Shulk
  • Mario
  • 23,448 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 11:28 AM

"Pain" is actually a complicated subject, since there are different kinds of pain... Pain is both sensory and emotional. Like for example, you step on a nail which damages your nerves and sends signals up to your brain which make you emotionally distressed ("Ow, that hurts!") about your injury. While bugs can get hurt physically, we don't know if that translates into an emotional experience.

More intelligent creatures can feel pain in a way that we can understand, though. Unlike what every fisher has told you, fish do in fact feel pain and even fear in ways similar to a human. Some countries, like Germany, have even banned certain types of fishing for this reason.


Man that makes me not want to fish ever again! But that makes sense with the emotional response to the pain.

Last night there was a bee on a spoon in my bathroom. My roommate didn't want to take a shower out of fear or even brush her teeth. Finally after I was done with everything I took a cup, put it over the spoon stuffed a towel over it and then removed the spoon and brought the bee outside.

Whenever I see a bug that's hurt, I normally kill it because it looks like it's feeling pain. If it's able to recover I'll help it on it's way, but most times if they loose a leg or something more extreme, I just put them out of their misery.

I can see other animals feeling pain from injury. I just never really thought about bugs to much. I just instinctively try to help them. Like when it rains and worms are on the side walk, I put them in a nice pile of dirt. I couldn't imagine being stuck out in the sun and drying up until I die. That must be a horrible way to go!

Lovesig2_zps472d6444.jpg


#6 Smash

Smash
  • Zelda
  • 5,432 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 12:15 PM

I agree that they don't feel pain the way we do but it's still cruel for us to consider doing something terrible to them. Good old human empathy will do that.

Fun fact: Plants, in a way, can feel pain. Some species, if they're being attack, send out chemical signals to other members of their species.

#7 Shulk

Shulk
  • Mario
  • 23,448 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 01:17 PM

Plants also carry DNA and you can match the flower of a tree to the exact tree it came from! I thought that was so cool when I learned that.

But yeah, I'd never torture a bug of any animal for fun. I actually like to feed ants and watch them work. And I think it's amazing that an ant cares so much that it will drag their dead back to their nest.

Lovesig2_zps472d6444.jpg


#8 Wappa

Wappa
  • Rattata
  • 205 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 07:09 PM

I'm not sure. That is a good question though. There was this bug loose in the car, got it by the attena and flung it out the window. Then I thought," I wonder how much that hurt?"

#9 Shulk

Shulk
  • Mario
  • 23,448 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 07:11 PM

Glad to see I'm not the only one to think about it.

Lovesig2_zps472d6444.jpg


#10 Sanji07

Sanji07

    Nya

  • Navi
  • 4,616 Posts

Posted 20 April 2012 - 07:40 PM

I never kill bugs, whether or not they feel pain. Not even cockroaches (even though my dad kills them...>->).
Posted Image
Posted Image